Loading...
|
Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:
https://nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/handle/140.119/38843
|
| Title: | 不動產估價最終估值之形成－權重模式、估值差異與市場景氣之影響
The formation of final value of real estate appraisal: Weight model, appraisal bias and real estate cycle |
| Authors: | 游適銘 |
| Contributors: | 張金鶚
游適銘 |
| Keywords: | 不動產估價
買賣實例比較法
估價權重
估值差異
不景氣低估
Real estate appraisal
Sales comparison approach
Reconciliation
Correlation
Weight of appraisal
Appraisal bias |
| Date: | 2009 |
| Issue Date: | 2010-04-09 18:40:09 (UTC+8) |
| Abstract: | 不動產估價一般需採比較法、收益法及成本法等三種方法查估。不動產估價最終估值決定須進行協調(reconciliation)，協調的目的係為完成關聯(correlation)之步驟，就各種方法資料之質量及優缺點進行分析。為使不動產估價對於比較法三件買賣實例，及三種方法估值採賦予權重之決定方式提供量化解釋，本文分別建立比較法內部及三種方法外部權重模型。內部權重部分，買賣實例（市場）比較法一般需蒐集數個比較標的，經調整後之試算價格決定比較價格。國外以數學計算式計算實例權重雖已相當普遍，但目前尚無應用特徵效用模式，解讀實例權重形成與比較標的內部條件之關聯。本文以2007年及2008年地價基準地6,435筆買賣實例建構特徵權重模型，發現比較法買賣實例權重受價格型態、交易日期接近性、是否屬近鄰地區、實例差異百分率絕對值加總、實例比較項目修正數、其他兩個實例相對值等自變數影響顯著。
欲探討成本法估值是否與成交價存在差異，以作為外部權重設定之基礎，本文以北部地區986筆交易案例，由估價人員逐筆以成本法估計成本價格，俾與成交價格比較。發現成本價格有高估之系統性偏誤現象，分量迴歸(quantile regression)分析實證認為成本法並未因屋齡較新之建物有較高精度。另發現房地交易價格愈高、建物單價愈高、總樓層數愈高、移轉樓層愈低、建物面積愈小、建築工期愈長及利潤率愈小者；估值差異愈小。
外部權重分為三部分，首先將估價過程中之諸項因子，以分析階層程序法(AHP)專家問卷，彙整各種方法權重因子；其次，基於最適加權平均模式在於使三種方法估值總誤差最小之觀點，經由數學計算方程式建構2,150筆基準地三種方法標準差及相關係數模型以計算權重。第三、為了瞭解比較估值、收益估值與土地開發分析估值之關聯，本文將2,150筆三種估價方式權重建立聯立模型，以三階段最小平方法(3SLS)進行估計。實證模型系統加權解釋力甚高，且三種方式權重之自變數多符合預期並顯著，顯見三種方式之關聯性。
最後，不動產估價仍需考慮一般因素，如金融海嘯對全球金融及房地產市場，其影響力無遠弗屆，最終估值之決定即需考慮市場景氣對最終估值之影響。為探討對於(不)景氣時是否(低)高估？影響(低)高估與否之影響因素為何？本文以2002年至2004年國內某金融機構對房屋貸款20,532件之估值，以二項式邏輯特(Binary Logit)模型分析。實證結果發現於不景氣時期抵押貸款低估機率提高，景氣時期則無高估現象。綜上，本文以權重模式、估值差異及市場景氣影響探討不動產估價最終估值之形成，於權重模型建構及預測上，非如以往文獻僅對估值預測，而係就權重預測。於加權平均應用上，外生變數之迴歸係數可作為權重設定之參考。本文直接探討最終估值形成之權重核心，冀使估價之客觀性及科學化程度提高。
Real estate appraisal comprises the sales comparison, income, and cost approaches to value in general. The purpose of reconciliation is to complete the procedure of correlation and analyze the qualitative and quantitative strengths and weaknesses of different approach data. In order to assist quantifiable explanation when weighted average for three comparables in the Sales comparison approach and indicated values from three approaches are applied, this paper constructs internal and external weight models respectively. For internal weight model, this paper examines the correlation between weight and internal attributes of 6,345 sales comparables from land value benchmark in 2007 and 2008 adopting the hedonic price model. The outcome shows the price type, the proximity of transaction date, inside the neighborhood area or not, total gross adjustment as %, numbers of adjustments and the attributes of other two comparables considered in one appraisal are significant on the weight of comparables.
To explore whether the cost approach causes bias or not, and make it reference for establishment of external weight model, this paper compares the cost value, appraised by valuers applying the cost approach individually, from a sample of 986 transactions of properties sold in 2007 and 2008 in northern Taiwan, to sale price and finds the cost value is higher than sale price on average. It proves that the reliability of the cost approach is comparatively questionable due to its systematic bias of overestimation. With quantile regression, the outcome shows that the precision of cost value won’t increase for newer buildings. In addition, this paper finds the more the total property sales amount, the higher the unit construction fee, the higher building, the lower story, the smaller area, the longer construction years of properties, and the smaller profit rate; the smaller the bias.
There are three parts for external weights. First, AHP expert questionare is adopted to combine weight factor from each approach. Secondly, based on the logic that the best way to assign weights on three appraisal approaches is to get the minimum total error, this paper calculates the standard error and correlation indicators from three approaches using 2,150 land value benchmarks. Thirdly, in order to realize the weights correlation among the sales comparison value, income capitalization value and land development analysis value, this paper builds a model based on the three-stage least squares method simultaneous equation (3SLS). The empirical result shows system weighted R2 is high and most attributes on the weights of three indication of value are significant and are consistent with expected sign, which means the model fit is good and how the weights of three methods correlate.
Finally, general factor also needs to be considered in real estate appraisal. For instance, financial tsunami exerts powerful influence on financial and real estate market globally, which makes it necessary to consider real estate cylce influence when seeking the final value. In order to discuss whether the appraisal value of mortgage is smaller (greater) or not when the market is bearish (bullish) and the corresponding factors, this paper collects 20,532 mortgage appraisal value from one bank from 2002 to 2004. With Binary Logit model, this paper finds the probability of lower appraisal is greater in bear market. The outcome confirms two hypotheses of this paper. However, overestimation is not confirmed in bull market. To sum up, this thesis researches the formation of final value of real estate appraisal by discussing weight model, appraisal bias and influence of real estate cycle. For weight model construction and forecasting, this dissertation forecasts weight directly, instead of value like most literature focus. The regression coefficients estimated from factors during the procedure of each approach could serve for reference if weighted average is applied reconciling the value conclusion by valuers. By delving into the core issue of value formation, it hopes to elevate the degree the objectivity and science of real estate appraisal. |
| Reference: | 刀根薰著、陳名揚譯，1993，『競賽式決策制定法- AHP 入門』，台北：建宏出版社。
內政部，1993，『中華民國地政史』，台北：內政部編印。
______，2002，「改進地價制度之研究」，內政部91年自行研究報告。
______，2007，「地價基準地與區段地價制度結合之研究」，內政部96年自行研究報告。
______，2008，「不動產估價相關參數應用之研究」，內政部97年自行研究報告。
______，2008，「97年地價基準地選定與查估作業手冊」，台北：內政部編印。
日本不動產研究所，2003，『日本不動產鑑定評價基準』，東京：住宅新報社。
吳森田，1994，「所得、貨幣與房價—近二十年台北地區之觀察」，『住宅學報』，2：49-65。
李月華，1999，「台北市住宅價格模型之研究」，淡江大學管理科學學系博士論文：台北。
沈中華、林公韻，2005，「違約機率預測與極端值」，『財務金融學刊』，13(3)。
沈中華、謝孟芬，2006，「金融業提列備抵呆帳與景氣循環、法規之關聯性分析-以49個國家為例」，『財金論文叢刊』，4：1-23。
林左裕，2003，『不動產投資管理』，台北：智勝公司。
林秋瑾、黃佩玲，1995，「住宅價格與總體經濟變數關係之研究—以向量自我迴歸模式(VAR) 進行實證」，『政大學報』，71：143-160。
林秋瑾、楊宗憲、張金鶚，1996，「住宅價格指數之研究－以台北市為例」，『住宅學報』，4：1-30。
林英彥，2006，『不動產估價』十一版，台北：文笙書局。
林祖嘉，1992，「台灣地區房租與房價關係之研究」，『台灣銀行季刊』，43(1)：279-312。
林祖嘉、林素菁，1996，「住宅需求、住宅價格與貸款成數」，『台灣經濟學會年會論文集』，203-219。
夏郭賢、吳漢雄，1998，「灰關聯分析之線性數據前處理探討」，『灰色系統學刊』，1(1)：47-53。
張怡文、江穎慧與張金鶚，2009，「分量迴歸在大量估價模型之應用－非典型住宅估價之改進」，『都市與計劃』，36(3)：281-304。
張金鶚，1995，「台灣地區住宅價格指數之研究」，行政院經建會委託研究報告。
張金鶚、劉秀玲，1993，「房地產品質、價格與消費者物價指數之探討」，『國立政治大學學報』，67：369-400。
張金鶚、陳明吉、鄧筱蓉與楊智元，2009，「台北市房價泡沫知多少？－房價vs.租金、房價vs.所得」，『住宅學報』，18(2)：1-22。
張麗姬，1994，「從遠期契約和現貨的角度論預售屋和成屋的價格關係---以台北市為例」，『住宅學報』，2：67-85。
陳明吉、曾婉婷，2007，「台灣不動產市場從眾行為之檢視」，『管理與系統』，即將出版。
陳彥仲、林國民，1998 ，「臺灣都市住宅屬性隱含需求分析－以高雄市為例」，『成功大學學報』，33(人文．社會篇) ：303-320。
游適銘，2007，「不動產估價方法權重關係之探討－以地價基準地為例」，『土地經濟年刊』，18：86-88。
游適銘，2009，「部分調整行為之估價平滑－以臺中市地價基準地重估價為例」，『2009土地學術研討會論文集』。
游適銘、張金鶚，2009，「買賣實例比較法實例權重之分析與模式建立」，『都市與計劃』(已接受)。
游適銘、張金鶚，2010，「不同估價方法之權重分析與模式建立－地價基準地之探討」，『台灣土地研究』，(已接受)
楊松齡、游適銘，2010，「房地價格分離之剩餘歸屬探討—由產權結構之觀點」，『台灣土地研究』，13(1)。
楊蓁海，2006，「我國銀行授信行為與景氣循環的關係：兼論新版巴賽爾資本協定的順循環影響效果暨其因應之道」，『中央銀行季刊』，28(1)：43-72。
廖咸興、李阿乙、梅建平，1999，『不動產投資概論』，台北：華泰書局。
廖咸興、張芳玲，1997，「不動產評價模式特徵價格法與逼近調整法之比較」，「住宅學報」，5：17-35。
龔永香、江穎慧、張金鶚，2007，「客觀標準化不動產估價之可行性分析─市場比較法應用於大量估價」，『住宅學報』，16(2)：23-42。
Adelman, I. & Griliches, Z., 1961, “On an Index of Quality Change, Journal of the American Statistical Association”, 56: 535-546.
Altman, E. I. & Saunders, A., 2001, ”An analysis and critique of the BIS proposal on capital adequacy and ratings,” Journal of Banking & Finance, 25(1): 25.
Anglin, P. M., Rutherford, R. C. & Springer, T. M., 2003, “The Trade-Off Between the Selling Price of Residential Properties and Time-on-the-Market: The Impact of Price Setting”, Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 26(1): 95-111.
Appraisal Institute, 1967, Appraisal Terminology and Handbook(5th Edition), Chicago.
________________2000, Uniform Standards for Federal Land Acquisitions, Chicago.
________________2008, The Appraisal of Real Estate (13trd Edition), Chicago.
Asabere, P. K. & Huffman, F. E., 1993, ”Price Concessions, Time on Market, and the Actual Sale Price of Homes”, Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 6(2): 167-174.
Azali, M., Habibullah, M. S. and Baharumshah, A. Z., 2001, “Does PPP hold between Asian and the Japanese economies: evidence using panel unit root and panel cointegration”, Japan and the World Economy, 13: 35-50.
Babcock, F. M., 1924, The Appraisal of Real Estate, New York: the Macmillan Company
Babcock, H. A., 1968, Appraisal Principles and Procedures (Homewood, Illinois: Richard D. Irwin, Inc.), Exhibit 6-1: 121.
Benston, G. & Smith, C. W., 1976, “A Transaction Cost Approach to the Theory of Financial Intermediation,” Journal of Finance, 31: 215–231.
Berger, A. N. & Udell, G. F., 2002, “Small Business Credit Availability and Relationship Lending: The Importance of Bank Organizational Structure”, The Economic Journal, 112: 32-53.
Bernanke, B. S. & Gertler, M., 1995, “Inside the Black Box: The Credit Channel of Monetary Policy Transmission,” The Journal of Economic Perspectives, 9(4): 27.
Blauvelt, D. G., 1978, “Correlation: What’s that?,” The Real Estate Appraiser, 5: 21–22.
Boot, A. W. A. & Thakor, A. V., 2000, “Can Relationship Banking Survive Competition？” Journal of Finance : 679-713.
Burton, J. H., 1982, “Evolution of Income Approach.“, Chicago: American Inst. of Real Estate Appraisal: 64-64.
Calhoun, C. A., 2001, “Property Valuation Methods and Data in the United States,” Housing Finance International, 16(2): 12-23.
Cannaday, R. E. and Colwell, P. F., 1995, “The Cost Approach: Appraisal Gone Wrong?”, Illinois Real Estate Letter, hiver-printemps:1-4.
Cannaday, R. E. and Sunderman, M. A., 1986, ”Estimation of Depreciation for Single-Family Appraisals,” Journal of the American Real Estate & Urban Economics Association, 14, 2:255-273.
Chan, Y. S. & Thakor, A. V., 1987, “Collateral and Competitive Equilibria with Moral Hazard and Private Information,” The Journal of Finance, 42(2): 3459.
Christensen, B., 1986, ”Subsidized housing and the three approaches”, The Real Estate Appraiser /analyst.52
Clapp, J. M., 1990a, “A Methodology for Constructing Vacant Land Price Indices,” Journal of American Real Estate Economics,.18(3): 274-293.
___________1990b, “A New Test for Equitable Real Estate Tax Assessment,” Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economic. 3(3): 233-249.
Clayton, J. D., Geltner, and S. W. Hamilton, 2001, “Smoothing in Commercial Property Valuation: Evidence from Individual Appraisals”, Real Estate Economics, 29(3) 337-360.
Colwell, P. F., Cannaday, R. E. & Wu, C. C., 1983, “The Analytical Foundations of Adjustment Grid Methods” , Real Estate Economics. 11(1):11-29.
Colwell, P. F., & Trefzger, J. W., 1994, "Allocation, externalities, and building value ", The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 8(1): 53-69.
Creteau, P. G., 1974, ”Real Estate Appraising (step-by-step) ,” Castle Pub. Co., Portland.
Culver, S. E. and Papell, D. H., 1999, “Long-Run Purchasing Power Parity with Short-Run Data: Evidence with a Null Hypothesis of Stationary,” Journal of International Money and Finance, 18: 751–768.
Cutsinger, S., 1978, ”The cost approach may produce the lowest valuation estimate”, The Real Estate Appraiser, 44(1): 35.
Daly, J., 2001, “Economic Sustainability in Real Estate Markets: Implications on a Federal State”, Fourth Sharjah Urban Planning Symposium.
Derbes, M. J., 1982, “Is the cost approach obsolete?,” Appraisal Journal, 50(4): 581.
Diaz, J., 1997, ”An Investigation into the Impact of Previous Expert Value Estimate on Appraisal Judgment”, Journal of Real Estate Research, 13(1):57-66.
Diaz, J. and Hansz, J. A., 1997, “How Valuers Use the Value Opinions of Others”, Journal of Property Valuation and Investment, 15(3):256-260.
Diaz, J. and Wolverton, M., 1998, “A Longitudinal Examination of the Appraisal Smoothing Hypothesis”, Real Estate Economics, 26(2):349-358.
Diaz, J., 1997, “An Investigation into the Impact of Previous Expert Value Estimate on Appraisal Judgment”, Journal of Real Estate Research, 13(1):57-66.
Dotzour, M. G., 1990, ”An Empirical Analysis of the Reliability and Precision of the Cost Approach in Residential Appraisal”, Journal of Real Estate Research,(5).
Dotzour, M. G., Moorhead, E., and Winkler, D., 1998, “The Impact of Auctions on Residential Sales Prices in New Zealand," Journal of Real Estate Research, 16(1).
Drives Jonas/IPD, 1990, “The Variance in Valuations,” Drives Jona/Investment Property databank, London.
Dubin, R. A., 1992, “Spatial Autocorrelation and Neighbourhood Quality”, Regional Science and Urban Economics, 22: 433-452.
Ellwood, L. W., 1977, Ellwood Tables for Real Estate Appraising and Financing, 4th edition, American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers, Cambridge, MA: Ballinger Publishing Company.
Entreken, H. C. and Kapplin, S. D., 1977, ”the proper place and purpose of the cost approach”, The Real Estate Appraiser (January/february), 5-9.
Featherston, J. B., 1968, “Correlation and Final Value Estimate”, the Real Estate Appraiser: 40–46.
Follain, J. R. and Malpezzi, S., 1980, “Dissecting Housing Value and Rent”, Washington, DC: The Urban Institute.
Frew, J. and Jud, G. D., 2003, “Estimating the Value of Apartment Building”, The Journal of Real Estate Research, 25(1):77-86.
Galleshaw, M. W., 1992, “Appropriate Uses of Economic Characteristics in the Sales Comparison Approach,” The Appraisal Journal. Chicago. 60(1): 91-98.
Graff, R. and Young, M. S., 1999, ”The Magnitude of Random Appraisal Error in Commercial Real Estate Valuation”, Journal of Real Estate Research, 17(2):33-54.
Gwin, C. R. & Maxam, C. L., 2002, “Why do Real Estate Appraisals Nearly Always Equal Offer Price? A Theoretical Justification”, Journal of Property Investment & Finance, 20(3): 242-253.
Gwin, C. R., Ong, S. E. & Spieler, A. C., 2006, “Real Estate Appraisal and Transaction Price: An Empirical Evaluation of Alternative Theories”, Journal of Housing Research, 15(1).
Hagood, W. D., 1978, “Reconciliation Analysis, formerly called Correlation”, the Real Estate Appraiser: 42-44.
Hansz, J. A., 2004, “Prior Transaction Price Induced Smoothing: Testing and Calibrating the Quan-Quigley Model at the Disaggregate Level”, Journal of Property Research, 21(4):321-336.
Harrison, H. S., 1989, ”Income properties”, New Haven, Conn.:H2 Company, 13-26.
Heaton, H. B., 1990, “Choosing the Weights in Appraisal Correlation”, Journal of Property Tax Management 2, 1: 28-33.
Heaton, H. B., 1993, “Three Approaches to Value: Same Formula, Radically Different Assumptions," Journal of Property Tax Management. 4(4): 23-31.
Hentschel, J. J. and Tosh, D. S., 1982, “The appraiser’s conscience: Final Correlation,” the Real Estate Appraiser and Analyst: 55-59.
Hodges, M. B., 2007, “Three Approaches?,” The appraisal Journal, Winter: 34.
Hollebaugh, C. W., 1962, “Correlation- the “Heart” of the Appraisal Process,” The Residential Appraiser: 17-20.
Howard, C. G., David, M. and Michael, M., 1997, Hardcover real estate valuation in global markets, Appraisal Institute
Hwang, C. L. and Yoon, K., 1981, Muliple Attribute Decision Making Methods and Applications: A State-of-the-Art Survey, Springer-Verlag, New York.
International Valuation Standard Committee, 2007, International Valuation Standard, eighth Edition, London.
Isakson, H. R., 2002, ”The Linear Algebra of the Sales Comparison Approach., Journal of Real Estate Research”, 24(2): 117-128.
Isakson, H. R., 1986, “The Nearest Neighbors Appraisal Technique: An Alternative to the Adjustment Grid Methods,” Journal of the American Real Estate and Urban Economics Association 14(2): 274-286.
Jensen, D. L., 1988, “The use of Multiple Linear Regression in Residential Land Valuation”, Property Tax Journal,7, 4: 215-241.
Jensen, D. L., 1988, ”The use of Multiple Linear Regression in Residential Land Valuation,” Property Tax Journal, 7(3): 215-241.
Jud, G. D., Winkler D. T. and Kissling, G. E., 1995, ”Price Spreads and Residential Housing Market Liquidity”, The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 11(3): 251-60.
Kahn, S. A. and Case, F. E., 1977, Real Estate Appraisal and Investment, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., New York.
Kahneman, D. and Tversky, A., 1973, ”On the Psychology of Prediction., Psychological Review”, 80(4):237-251.
Kang, H. B. & Reichert, A. K., 1991, “An Empirical Analysis of Hedonic Regression and Grid-Adjustment Techniques in real estate appraisal”, AREUEA Journal. 19: 70-91.
Kennedy, P., 1998, “Teaching undergraduate econometrics: A suggestion for fundamental change,” American Economic Review. 88(2): 487-491.
Kenneth, J. A. , 1964, “The role of securities in the optimal allocation of risk bearing,” Review of Economic Studies, 31(2): 91-96.
Kinnard, W. N. & Boyce, B. N., 1978, “An Introduction to Appraisal Real Property”, Chicago: Society of Real Estate Appraisers.
Kinnard, W. N., 1971, “Income Property Valuation”, Heath Lexington Books, Lexington, Mass, second edition., 442-443.
Kinnard, W. N., Lenk, M. M., & Worzala, E. M., 1997, “Client Pressure in the Commercial Appraisal Industry: How Prevalent Is It?, Journal of Property Valuation and Investment, 15(3): 233-244.
Koenker, R. and Bassett, G. W., 1978, “Regression Quantiles”, Econometrica, 46(1): 211-244.
Koenker, R. and Hallock, K. F. 2001, “Quantile Regression”, Journal of Economic Perspectives, 15(4): 143-156.
Kuan, C. M., 2003, “An Introduction To Quantile Regression”, Institute of Economics Academia Sinica.
Kummerow, M., 2003, “Theory of real estate valuation: an alternative way to teach real estate price estimation methods,” research monograph, Department of Land Economy and Valuation, Curtin University, Perth, 29.
Kurlowicz, T., James F. I. and McFadden, J. J., 2003, Planning For Business Owners and Professionals 9th Edition, The American College, 413-414.
LaCour-Little, M., & Green, R. K., 1998, “Are Minorities or Minority-Neighborhoods More Likely to Get. Low Appraised Values?” Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics 16, 3: 301-315.
Lancaster, K., 1965, “The Theory of Qualitative Linear Systems”, Econometrica, 33, 2:395-409.
Lentz, G.. H. & Wang, K., 1998, “Residential Appraisal and the Lending Process: A Survey of Issues”, Journal of Real Estate Research, 15, 1/2: 11-39.
Levy, D. & Schuck, E., 1999, “The influence of clients on valuations”, Journal of Property Valuation and Investment, 17, 4: 380-400.
Lin T. C. and Chen, W. C., 2006, ”Estimation of Depreciation for Residential Properties- Scientific Discovery or Rule of Thumb”, 23rd Pan Pacific Congress
Luckett, C. A., 1988, “Personal Bankruptcies”, Federal Reserve Bulletin, 74: 591-603.
Lusht, K. M., 1996, “A Comparison of Prices Brought by English Auction and Private Negotiations”, Journal of Real Estate Economics, 24, 5:17-530.
____________2001, ”Real Estate Valuation- Principles and Applications”, Philadelphia: KML Publishing.
Malpezzi, S., Ozanne, L. and Thibodeau, T. G., 1987 ,”Microeconomic Estimates of Housing Depreciation”, Land Economics, 63, 4:372-385.
Matysiak, G. and Wang, P., 1995, “Commercial Property Market Prices and Valuation: Analyzing the Correspondence,” Journal of Property Research, 12: 181-202.
Menkohoff, Neuberger & Suwanaporn, 2006, “Collateral-based Lending in Emerging Markets: Evidence from Thailand,” Journal of Banking and Finance, 30, pp. 1-21
Miller, G. H. and Gilbeau, K. W., 1988 “Residential Real Estate Appraisal”, Prentice Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey
Ong, S. E., Lusht, K. and Mak, C. Y., 2005, “Factors Influencing Auction Outcomes: Bidder Turnout, Auction Houses and Market Conditions,” Journal of Real Estate Research, 27(2): 77–91.
Pagourtzi, E., Assimakopoulos, V., Hatzichristos, T. and French, N., 2003, “Real Estate Appraisal: A Review of Valuation Methods,” Journal of Property Investment & Finance 21(4): 383-401.
Quan, D. C., 2002, “Market Mechanism Choice and Real Estate Disposition : Search vs Auction”, Journal of Real Estate Economics, 30(3):365-384.
Quan, D. C. and Quigley, J. M., 1991, “Price Formation and the Appraisal Function in Real Estate Markets” Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 4(2):127-46.
Rand, S. J., 1986, ”Cost approach to value”, Appraisal Journal, LIV(3): 367-375.
Ratcliff, R. U., 1972, “Valuation for Real Estate Decisions”, Santa Cruz: Democrat Free Press
Rattermann, M. R, 2007, ”Appraising Residential Property in a Changing Market”, The Appraisal Journal, 4: 14-23.
Rosen, S., 1974, “Hedonic Prices and Implicit Markets: Product Differentiation in Pure Competition”, Journal of Political Economy, 82, 1: 34-55.
Saaty, T. L., 1980, Analytic Hierarchy Process, Mcgrawhill, New York.
Shenkel, W. M.,1992, Real Estate Appraisal, South-Western Publishing Co., Cincinnati, Ohio
Shimizu and Nishimura, 2006, “Biases in Appraisal Land Price Information: The Case of Japan”, Journal of Property Investment and Finance, 24, 2: 150-175.
Sirmans. G. S., Macpherson, D. A. and Zietz, E. N., 2005, "The Composition of Hedonic Pricing Models," Journal of Real Estate Literature, 13(1): 3-43.
Smith, B. C., 2004, “Economic depreciation of residential real estate: Micro level space and time analysis”, Real Estate Economics, 32(1):161-180.
Smolen, G. E. & Hambleton, D. C., 1997, “Is the Real Estate Appraiser’s Role Too Much to Expect?” The Appraisal Journal, 65(1): 9-17.
Springer, T. M., 1996, “Single-Family Housing Transactions: Seller Motivation, Price, and. Marketing Time“, Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics, 13:237-254.
Tchira, A., 1979, “Comparable sales selection: a computer approach“, The Appraisal Journal, 48(1): 86-98.
Theil, H., 1971, “An Economic Theory of the Second Moments of Disturbances of Behavioral Equations,” The American Economic Review, 61(1), 190 - 94.
Todora, J. & Whiterell, D., 2002, “Automating the Sales Comparison Approach“, Assessment Journal, 9(1):25-33.
Tversky, A. and Kahneman, D. 1974, “Judgement Under Uncertainty,” Science, 185, 1122–1131.
Vandell, K. D., 1991, “Optimal Comparable Selection and Weighting in Real Property Valuation“, Real Estate Economics, 19(2): 213.
Ventolo, W. L. and M.R. William, 2001, “Fundamentals of Real Estate Appraisal, 8th edition”, Dear Born Real Estate Education
Wolverton, M. L., 1998, ”Empirical analysis of the breakdown method of estimating physical depreciation”, The Appraisal Journal, 66(2):163-171.
Wolverton, M. L.,1996, “Investigation into Price Knowledge Induced Comparable Sale Selection Bias”, Georgia State University
Wolverton, M. L. and Gallimore, P., 1999, “Client Feedback and the Role of the Appraiser,’ General Journal of Real Estate Research, 18(2-3).
Woolery, A., 1990, Property Tax Principles and Practice, Land Reform Training Institute..
Yiu, C. Y., Tang, B. S., Chiang, Y. H. and Choy, L. H. T., 2006 “Alternative Theories of Appraisal Bias”, Journal of Real Estate Literature, 14, 3, 341-344.
You, S. M. & Chang, C. O., 2009, ” Weight Regression Model from the Sales Comparison Approach,” Property Management, 27(5)：302-318.
Zsamboki, B., 2002, “The effects of prudential regulation on banks’ procyclical behaviour,” in Studies on the procyclical behaviour of banks, National Bank of Hungary Occasional Papers, 10. |
| Description: | 博士
國立政治大學
地政研究所
94257503
98 |
| Source URI: | http://thesis.lib.nccu.edu.tw/record/#G0094257503 |
| Data Type: | thesis |
| Appears in Collections: | [地政學系] 學位論文
|
Files in This Item:
| File |
Description |
Size | Format | |
|---|
| 750302.pdf | | 2946Kb | Adobe PDF2 | 6895 | View/Open |
|
All items in 政大典藏 are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved.
|
