政大機構典藏-National Chengchi University Institutional Repository(NCCUR):Item 140.119/81347

政大典藏 > College of Social Science > Department of Public Administration > Periodical Articles > Item 140.119/81347

Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item: https://nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/handle/140.119/81347

Title:	論轉型正義與台灣行政國正當性的重生
Other Titles:	Transitional Justice and the Re-born of the Legitimate Administrative State in Taiwan
Authors:	陳敦源;張智凱 Chen, Don-yun;Chang, Chih-kai
Contributors:	公行系
Keywords:	轉型正義;行政國;官僚體系;正當性;民主轉型;施為觀點 Transitional Justice;Administrative State;Bureaucracy;Legitimacy;Democratic Transition;Agency Perspective
Date:	2014
Issue Date:	2016-02-19 15:10:03 (UTC+8)
Abstract:	台灣民主化所面對的轉型正義問題，大多圍繞著政治與人權的領域，鮮少討論官僚體系的轉型正義問題。本文從 Dwight Waldo 行政國的理論出發，討論民主國家公共行政追尋獨立正當性的意義與重要性；其次，引入 Terry Cooper 以降，行政倫理研究探討「公共行政倫理的理論基礎」時，在方法論上強調歷史文化演進的深刻反思、進行公共行政正當性之倫理性基礎深化的途徑。雖然，美國公共行政的發展並沒有民主轉型的問題，然而其思索建構公共行政正當性時，「面對國家歷史文化演進」的過程，卻是台灣公共行政獨立正當性的尋求，所同需處理的議題，亦即必須處理我國悠久官僚文明中「統治階層幫手」的角色認知問題。因此，台灣官僚體系轉型正義問題的處理，應該聚焦在喚起過去參與威權統治的罪惡感，進而集體反省台灣官僚體系獨立性的意義，以期讓台灣行政國正當性有重生的機會，在民主的價值上重新建構統治者與被統治者關係。本文最後提出三點建議，其一，台灣應該從行政國的觀點整理威權統治的資料並進行研究，以達到彰顯轉型正義並留存歷史事實的目的、其二，官僚體系的訓練中應該加入轉型正義的概念，藉由回顧過去威權統治下官僚違反正義行為，反思民主政治中官僚體系獨立正當性的意義，建議可以在「行政中立」訓練中加入相關轉型正義的相關資料；其三，關於公務人員體制的制度性改革，尤其是牽涉到官僚身分以及報酬的部份，應該站在轉型正義的角度，藉由公開、互動與專業的方式進行，以重構統治者與被統治者的關係。 In the past, the study of transitional justice is usually on politicians and the issue of human rights. Seldom are there discussions on the problem of bureaucracy and transitional justice. In this paper, authors use the argument of administrative state from Dwight Waldo to argue the importance of rebuilding legitimate administrative state in a transitional polity, such as Taiwan. The focus is to raise bureaucrat’s sense of “guilt” on participating in authoritarian ruling. Not until bureaucracy begins to collectively reflect their past roles played in the authoritarian regime, the reborn of bureaucratic independence and legitimate role in a democratic polity will not take place easily. The reform of the public service pension system (so-called the 18% issue) indicates a top-down effort to echo the call for transitional justice in the society. However, the reform is politically motivated and eventually disconnects with the purpose of rebuilding legitimate administrative state. Finally, authors propose three reform activities. First, on the issue of transitional justice in bureaucracy, documents’ collecting, preserving, and utilizing are the very first step toward rebuilding bureaucratic legitimacy. Second, the issued of transitional justice should be add to civil service training curriculum. Last, any reform on civil service institutions, especially on civil servant’s right to work and compensation, should be process in an open, interactive, and professional way.
Relation:	民主與治理, 1(1), 53-85
Data Type:	article
Appears in Collections:	[Department of Public Administration] Periodical Articles

Files in This Item:

File	Description	Size	Format
5385.pdf		507Kb	Adobe PDF2	1275	View/Open

社群 sharing

Loading...