Loading...
|
Please use this identifier to cite or link to this item:
https://nccur.lib.nccu.edu.tw/handle/140.119/146275
|
| Title: | 藉區域保障機制贏回性少數正義：美洲人權法院Vicky Hernandez et al. v. Honduras之個案研究
Bringing Justice Home for Sexual Minorities through Regional Protection Mechanism: A case Study of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights` Judgment of Vicky Hernandez et al., v. Honduras |
| Authors: | 洛景鐸
Lopez, Victor Hugo |
| Contributors: | 翁燕菁
Weng, Vivianne Y.-C.
洛景鐸
Victor Hugo Lopez |
| Keywords: | 迴力模式
區域保機制
美洲人權法
異性戀規範
LGBTIQ
LGBTIQ
Boomerang Pattern Model
Regional Protection Mechanism
Inter-American Court of Human Rights
Heteronormativity |
| Date: | 2023 |
| Issue Date: | 2023-08-02 12:57:03 (UTC+8) |
| Abstract: | 迴力鏢模式理論解釋何以民間社會尋求國際層級的支持，以便得以於求變之國內動員中獲得賦能。本論文藉由迴力鏢理論，檢視美洲人權法院就跨性別權利之里程碑裁判前後之歷程。宏都拉斯LGBTIQ社群將正義帶回家鄉的動員路上，2021年的Vicky Hernández et al. v. Honduras判決是重要的一步。然而，即使於區域層級獲得勝利，國內卻未見預期的改變或進步。依據國家遵從國際義務理論的綜整，本文主張，宏都拉斯未能有效履行這項判決衍生的義務，原因在於其嬴弱之國家體制以及威權甚或父權之制度。即使宏都拉斯具有物質面與社會面之脆弱性，仍然抗拒任何實質改變以遵從其國際義務。宏都拉斯的制度缺陷構成履行國際義務的主要障礙，跨性別女性的謀殺案格外具有故事性。
本論文自圍繞著迴力鏢路徑之理論框架與辯論著手文獻回顧，探討國家遵從國際規範之模式。次就個案研究，本文描繪宏都拉斯LGBTIQ成員之處境，並藉重性別研究之關鍵概念解釋宏都拉斯制度內之權力關係。於此訴訟前篇章後，本文挖掘美洲人權委員會及美洲人權法院之決定與認定，藉以確認本案於區域層級上所得出之結論，顯示LGBTIQ跨國網絡協作於區域層級上的成功。然而，自有限的官方出版與媒體報導，本案之後續追蹤管考並未揭示任何改變的正面跡象。透過與國會議員及地方人權工作者的訪談，本文最終確認迴力鏢效應並未於宏都拉斯發生。最終，本文嘗試識別宏都拉斯未能履行裁判結果並遵守其國際義務的原因。在五項國家遵從理論的限制性條件檢視下，本文主張，一個合理的國家體制搭配有運作效能之制度，應為國家遵從國際義務不可或缺之要件，特別是當社會中父權仍然強勢時。
The boomerang effect theory explains how civil society seeks support at the international level that enable their domestic mobilization for change. This thesis examines the process before and after a landmark decision on transgender rights of the Inter-American Court of Human Rights (IACtHR) through the boomerang framework. The 2021 judgment of Vicky Hernández et al., v. Honduras is an important step for the Honduran LGBTIQ community to bring justice home. However, even with this victory at the regional level, expected change or progress can hardly be identified or confirmed at the domestic level. Based on a synthesis of compliance theories, I argue that Honduras’s failure in implementing this judgment effectively is due to its weak statehood and authoritarian, or even patriarchal, institutions. Despite its material and social vulnerabilities, Honduras still resists any significant change to comply with its international obligations. The case of a transwoman’s murder is particularly storytelling regarding the Honduran institutional deficiencies which constitute principle barriers to compliance.
In this thesis, I started with a literature review on theoretical frameworks and debates around boomerang pattern for States’ compliance with international norms. For my case study, I describe the situation of LGBTIQ members in Honduras with the support of key concepts in gender studies to explain the power relationship within the Honduran institutions. Following the pre-litigation chapter, I explore the decisions and findings of both Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) and IACtHR to confirm that the conclusion of this case at the regional level is a success for LGBTIQ transnational networking. Nevertheless, based on a limited number of official publications and media reports, the follow-up of this judgment does not reveal any positive sign for change. Through interviews with a Congress member and local human rights activists, I can finally confirm that the boomerang effect did not take place back in Honduras. In the end, I try to identify the reasons why Honduras fails to implement this judgment and respect its international obligations. Under the five scope conditions in compliance theory, a reasonable statehood with functional institutions should be indispensable for compliance, especially when patriarchy remains strong in society. |
| Reference: | ABC News. 2017. “Femicide, Part 1: Honduras, one of the most dangerous Places to be a Woman.” YouTube. https://youtu.be/VERguOc0laE.
Allendoerfer, Michelle G., Amanda Murdie, and Ryan M. Welch. 2020. “The Path of the Boomerang: Human Rights Campaigns, Third-Party Pressure, and Human Rights.” International Studies Quarterly 64 (1): 111-119.
Alterio, Ana M. 2022. “Latin American Feminists, Gender, and the Binary System of Human Rights Protection.” American Journal of International Law 116:323-327. https://doi.org/10.1017/aju.2022.50.
Alvarado, Karol C. 2021. “Violence Against Trans Women in Public Spaces: Between sexual harassment and Transphobia.” Revista Latinoamericana de Derechos Humanos Volumen 32, no. No. 1 (Spring): 1-39. http://www.revistas.una.ac.cr/derechoshumanos.
Amaya, Alejandra, and Maria E. Calix. 2021. “La ONU manifiesta su preocupación por la aprobación de la reforma constitucional que impide el aborto y el matrimonio igualitario en Honduras.” Naciones Unidas en Honduras. https://honduras.un.org/es/108906-la-onu-manifiesta-su-preocupaci%C3%B3n-por-la-aprobaci%C3%B3n-de-la-reforma-constitucional-que-impide#_ftn1.
Balbis, Jorge. 2001. “Management of Social Transformations: NGOs, Governance and Development in Latin America and the Caribbean.” UNESCO. http://www.unesco.org/most.
Bamforth, Nicholas. 1997. “Understanding Lesbian and Gay Rights.” In Sexuality and Equality Law, 44. N.p.: Taylor & Francis Group.
Bassano, David. 2014. “The Boomerang Pattern: Verification and Modification.” Peace & Change 39 (1): 23-48.
Beach, Derek. 2017. “Process Tracing Methods in the Social Sciences.” Oxford University Press Vol. 2:1-21. 10.1093/acrefore/9780190228637.013.176.
Bettcher, Talia M. 2007. “Evil Deceivers and Make-Believers: On Transphobic Violence and the Politics of Illusion.” Hypatia Vol. 22, no. No. 3 (Summer): 43-65. Evil Deceivers and Make-Believers: On Transphobic Violence and the Politics of Illusion.
Bettcher, Talia M. 2014. “Trapped in the Wrong Theory: Rethinking Trans Oppression and Resistance.” Signs Vol 39, no. No. 2 (Fall 2014): 383-406. https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/673088.
Börzel, Tanja A., and Thomas Risse. 2013. “Human Rights in Areas of Limited Statehood: The New Agenda.” In The Persistent Power of Human Rights: From Commitment to Compliance, 63-84. Thomas Risse, Stephen C. Ropp, and Kathryn Sikkink ed. 10.1017/CBO9781139237161.007.
Burgerman, Susan D. 1998. “Mobilizing Principles: The Role of Transnational Activists in Promoting Human Rights Principles.” Human Rights Quarterly 20:905-923.
Burgos, Jorge. 2022. “Población LGBTIQ+ a la espera de cumplimiento de medidas de reparación dictadas por caso Vicky Hernández.” Criterio.hn. https://criterio.hn/poblacion-lgbtiq-a-la-espera-de-cumplimiento-de-medidas-de-reparacion-dictadas-por-caso-vicky-hernandez/.
“Canadian Institutes of Health Research-CIHR.” 2020. What is gender? What is sex? - CIHR. https://cihr-irsc.gc.ca/e/48642.html.
Centro de Derechos de Mujeres Honduras. 2022. “Honduras: Number of Femicides by Month 2021.” Statista. https://www.statista.com/statistics/1133354/number-femicides-month-honduras/.
Contreras-Garduño, Diana. 2014. “The Inter-American System of Human Rights.” The Sage Handbook of Human Rights, (January), 596-614. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/298821772.
Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos. 2020. “Audiencia Pública. Caso Vicky Hernández y otros Vs. Honduras. Parte 1.” YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5AXht8vR6l8&t=6194s&ab_channel=CorteInteramericanadeDerechosHumanos.
Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos. 2020. “Audiencia Pública. Caso Vicky Hernández y otros Vs. Honduras. Parte 2.” YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9rn4ctlOM2I&ab_channel=CorteInteramericanadeDerechosHumanos.
Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos. 2022. Caso Vicky Hernandez y Otras vs. Honduras Supervision de Sentencia. N.p.: Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos.
De Búrca, Gráinne, ed. 2022. Legal Mobilization for Human Rights. N.p.: Oxford University Press.
Department of International Law of the OAS. 1969. “American Convention of Human Rights Pact of "San Jose", Costa Rica.” Organization of American States: Multilateral Treaties. http://www.oas.org/dil/treaties_B-32_American_Convention_on_Human_Rights_sign.htm.
Diario El Heraldo. 2022. ““No es tema religioso, ni moral”: diputado Grajeda ante iniciativa de matrimonio de personas del mismo sexo.” El Heraldo. https://www.elheraldo.hn/honduras/congreso-nacional-matrimonio-gays-iniciativa-religion-victor-grajeda-DJ8182665.
Diario La Tribuna. 2021. “Comunidad LGTB protesta en Tegucigalpa, en exigencia al respeto de sus derechos (Video).” Diario La Tribuna. https://www.latribuna.hn/2021/05/17/comunidad-lgtb-protesta-exigiendo-respeto-a-sus-derechos-en-tegucigalpa-video/.
El Universal. 2023. “Las Trabajadoras Sexuales Tenemos Siempre un Pie en una Tumba, en un Hospital o en una Cárcel.” YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TabuSq-WM7s&t=527s&ab_channel=ElUniversal.
Federación Internacional de Derechos Humanos. 2015. “Honduras: Crímenes derivados del golpe de estado de 2009 deben ser investigados, aún sin la CPI.” FIDH. https://www.fidh.org/es/region/americas/honduras/honduras-crimenes-derivados-del-golpe-de-estado-de-2009-deben-ser.
Fernandez Muñoz, Alejandro, and Gloriana Rodriguez Alvarez. 2022. “In the Name of Vicky: Prosecuting Transfemicide in Honduras.” Peace Review, (October), 518-528. https://doi.org/10.1080/10402659.2022.2128999.
Ferrer McGregor, Eduardo. 2015. “The Constitutionalization of International Law in Latin America Conventionality Control The New Doctrine of The Inter-American Court of Human Rights.” AJIL Unbound 109:93-99. https://doi.org/10.1017/S2398772300001240.
Ghoshal, Neela, and Cristian González Cabrera. 2020. "Every Day I Live in Fear": Violence and Discrimination Against LGBT People in El Salvador, Guatemala, and Honduras, and Obstacles to Asylum in the United States. N.p.: Human Rights Watch. https://www.hrw.org/publications.
Goldberg, SuzanneB., ed. 2010. Sexuality and Equality Law. N.p.: Taylor & Francis Group.
Goldscheid, Julie, ed. 2013. Gender and Equality Law. N.p.: Ashgate.
Gomez, Maria M. 2013. Gender and Sexuality in Latin America - Cases and Decisions. Vol. No. 24. N.p.: Springer Netherlands.
Goodman, Ryan, and Derek Jinks. 2008. “Incomplete Internalization and Compliance with Human Rights Law.” The European Journal of International Law Vol. 19 (No. 04): 725-748. 10.1093/ejil/chn039.
Goodman, Ryan, and Derek Jinks. 2013. Socializing states: Promoting human rights through international law. N.p.: Oxford University Press.
Grajeda, Victor. 2023. Interview for Research in LGBTIQ Minorities Access to Justice in Honduras, Duration: 51:50. Taipei City, Taiwan.
Guillen Flores, Rosa J. 2014. Acoso Sexual Callejero y Sexismo Ambivalente en Jóvenes y Adultos Jóvenes de Lima, Thesis. Perú: Pontifica Universidad Católica Del Perú. http://hdl.handle.net/20.500.12404/5395.
Heinze, Eric. 1995. Sexual Orientation - A Human Right:An Essay on International Human Rights Law. N.p.: Springer Netherlands.
Henkin, Louis. 1980. “How Nations Behave.” Michigan Law Review 78 (No. 5): 825-828. https://doi.org/10.2307/1288079.
Hernández, Breidy. 2023. “Beca Vicky Hernández es una realidad en Honduras.” Criterio.hn. https://criterio.hn/beca-vicky-hernandez-es-una-realidad-en-honduras/.
Hernandez, Nestor. 2023. Interview for Research in LGBTIQ Minorities Access to Justice in Honduras, Duration: 59:21. Taipei City, Taiwan.
Inter-American Commission of Human Rights. 2018. Informe No. 157/18 caso 13.051, Informe Fondo Vicky Hernandez y Familia. https://www.oas.org.
Inter-American Commission on Human Rights and Organization of American States OAS. 2015. “Violence against Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Trans and Intersex Persons in the Americas.” II.
Inter-American Court of Human Rights. 2017. “Advisory Opinion OC-24/17: Gender Identity, and equality and Non-Discrimination of Same-Sex Couples.” San Jose, Costa Rica: Inter-American Court of Human Rights.
The Inter American Court of Human Rights. 2021. “Vicky Hernández et. al vs. Honduras,” Inter-American Court of Human Rights Judgement against the State of Honduras. Taipei City, Taipei: The Inter American Court of Human Rights.
Keck, Margaret, and Kathryn Sikkink. 1999. “Transnational Advocacy Networks in International and Regional Politics.” International Social Science Journal 51 (159): 89-101.
Lehoucq, Emilio, and Whitney K. Taylor. 2020. “Conceptualizing Legal Mobilization: How Should We Understand the Deployment of Legal Strategies?” Law and Social Inquiry Vol. 45 (1): 166-193. doi:10.1017/lsi.2019.59.
Levitt, Peggy, and Sally Mery. 2009. “Vernacularization on the ground: local uses of global women’s rights in Peru, China, India and the United States.” Global Networks 9 (4): 441-461. 1470–2266.
Lloyd, Moya. 2013. “Heteronormativity and/as Violence: The "Sexing" of Gwen Araujo.” Hypatia 28, no. No.4 (Fall): 818-834. https://www.jstor.org/stable/24542088.
Lynch, Nicolas. 2020. Para una crítica de la democracia en América Latina. N.p.: CLACSO. https://doi.org/10.2307/j.ctv1gm0209.
Mejia, Nadia. 2023. Interview for Research in LGBTIQ Minorities Access to Justice in Honduras, Duration: 01:07:52. Taipei City, Taiwan.
Merry, Sally E. 2006. Human Rights and Gender Violence: Translating International Law Into Local Justice (Book Review). N.p.: University of Chicago Press.
Miller, Lisa R., and Eric A. Grollman. 2015. “The Social Costs of Gender Nonconformity for Transgender Adults: Implications for Discrimination and Health.” Sociological Forum Vol. 30, no. No. 3 (September): 809-831. https://www.jstor.org/stable/43654134.
“Minority Definition & Meaning.” 2022. Merriam-Webster. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/minority.
Mitchell, Timothy. 1991. “The Limits of the State: Beyond Statist Approaches and Their Critics.” The American Political Science Review Vol. 85, no. No. 1 (March): 77-96. https://www.jstor.org/stable/1962879.
Molina Rodriguez, Nancy E., Oscar O. Guzman Cervantez, and Antar M. Guzman. 2015. “Identidades transgénero y transfobia en el contexto mexicano: Una aproximación narrativa.” Quaderns de Psicologia Vol. 17 (No 3): 71-82. http://dx.doi.org/10.5565/rev/qpsicologia.1279.
Nielsen, Laura B., Robert L. Nelson, and Roy Lancaster. 2010. “Individual Justice or Collective Legal Mobilization? Employment Discrimination Litigation in the Post Civil Rights United States.” Journal of Empirical Legal Studies Vol. 7 (2): 175-201. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1740-1461.2010.01175.x.
“Norm Definition & Meaning.” 2022. Merriam-Webster. https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/norm.
Now This News. 2019. “Argentina`s Secretary of Gender is Redefining Transgender Identity.” YouTube. https://youtu.be/lEgQFIFZijM.
Organization of American States (OAS). 1994. “The Inter-American Convention on Prevention, Punishment and Eradication of Violence Against Women "Belem Do Para."” (June). https://www.refworld.org/docid/3ae6b38b1c.html.
Pan American Health Organization. 2019. “Voices for Health: the story of collective organization by trans women in Chile.” YouTube. https://youtu.be/qH4PjC_p-zM.
PBS NewsHour. 2015. “Inside the `pure hell` of violence against Women in Honduras.” YouTube. https://youtu.be/eZ1l4WRt7Lo.
Peace Brigades International and German Civil Peace Service (CPS). 2022. “Breakdown in Order to Rebuild: Human Rights Situation in Honduras.” https://pbi-honduras.org/.
Red Lesbica Cattrachas. 2022. “Sistemas de Cattrachas.” Cattrachas. https://www.cattrachas.org/sistemas.
Risse, Thomas, Stephen C. Ropp, and Kathryn Sikkink, eds. 2013. The Persistent Power of Human Rights: From Commitment to Compliance. N.p.: Cambridge University Press.
Romero, Evan. 2014. “Resistencia LGBTI en Honduras | Destacados.” DW. https://www.dw.com/es/resistencia-lgbti-en-honduras/a-17817206.
Roth, Kenneth. 2015. “World Report 2015: World Report 2015: Honduras.” Human Rights Watch. https://www.hrw.org/world-report/2015/country-chapters/world-report-2015-honduras.
Roth, Kenneth. 2022. “Informe Mundial 2022: Honduras.” Human Rights Watch. https://www.hrw.org/es/world-report/2022/country-chapters/380720.
Ryan, Joelle R. 2008. “Death by Transphobia: Increasing Gender Awareness through Teaching the Day of Remembrance.” Transformations: The Journal of Inclusive Scholarship and Pedagogy Vol 19, no. No. 2 (Fall 2008): 81-91. https://www.jstor.org/stable/43505852.
Schilt, Kristen, and Laurel Westbrook. 2009. “Doing Gender, Doing Heteronormativity.” Gender & Society 23 (4): 440-464. https://doi.org/10.1177/0891243209340034.
Sierra Campos, Catalina D. 2022. “Identidad de género y sexo biológico: Una mirada desde la Corte Interamericana de Derechos Humanos en la sentencia Vicky Hernández y otras vs. Honduras, de 26 de marzo de 2021.” Revista Jurídica Digital UANDES 4 (2): 151-160.
“Signatario y ratificaciones - Convención Americana sobre Derechos Humanos.” n.d. OEA : Comisión Interamericana de Derechos Humanos. Accessed December 29, 2022. http://www.cidh.oas.org/basicos/Spanish/basicos2a.htm.
Sikkink, Kathryn. 1993. “Human Rights, Principled Issue-Network, and Sovereignty in Latin America.” International Organization 47, no. No. 3 (Summer): 411-441. https://www.jstor.org/stable/2706982.
Sikkink, Kathryn, Thomas Risse, and Stephen C. Ropp, eds. 2009. The Power of Human Rights: International Norms and Domestic Change. N.p.: Cambridge University Press.
Simmons, Beth A. 2009. Mobilizing for Human Rights: International Law in Domestic Politics. N.p.: Cambridge University Press.
“Sticky Institutions and The Future of Sexual Orientation Discrimination.” 2010. In Sexuality and Equality Law, edited by Suzanne B. Goldberg. N.p.: Taylor & Francis Group.
Stubbins Bates, Elizabeth. 2015. “Sophisticated Constructivism in Human Rights Compliance Theory.” The European Journal of International Law 25 (No.4): 1170-1181. 10.1093/ejil/chu084.
Transformative Justice Law Project Illinois. n.d. “Quick Guide to the Criminalization of Transgender and Gender Non-Conforming People.” Illinois. Accessed 2022. https://chartreuse-roadrunner-rpsl.squarespace.com/.
Tucker, Duncan. 2016. “Homophobia in Honduras: growing attacks on LGBT activists - Index on Censorship Index on Censorship.” Index on Censorship. https://www.indexoncensorship.org/2016/04/magazine-honduras-rainbow-warriors-the-dangers-of-being-an-lgbt-activist/.
Ulises Borgogno, Ignacio G. 2010. “La Transfobia en América Latina y Caribe: Un Estudio en el Marco de REDLACTRANS.” redlactrans.org. http://redlactrans.org.ar/site/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/La-Transfobia-en-America-Latina-y-el-Caribe.pdf.
United Nations (UN). 1948. “Universal Declaration of Human Rights.” OHCHR. https://www.ohchr.org/en/universal-declaration-of-human-rights.
Zerón, Amelia. 2020. “Asesinaron también a las testigas de muerte de Vicky Hernández.” Reportar Sin Miedo. https://reportarsinmiedo.org/2020/11/12/dos-de-las-testigas-de-la-muerte-de-vicky-hernandez-fueron-asesinadas/. |
| Description: | 碩士
國立政治大學
國際研究英語碩士學位學程(IMPIS)
110862023 |
| Source URI: | http://thesis.lib.nccu.edu.tw/record/#G0110862023 |
| Data Type: | thesis |
| Appears in Collections: | [國際研究英語碩士學位學程] 學位論文
|
Files in This Item:
| File |
Description |
Size | Format | |
|---|
| 202301.pdf | | 7656Kb | Adobe PDF2 | 142 | View/Open |
|
All items in 政大典藏 are protected by copyright, with all rights reserved.
|
